知Yizhi Daily
← Back to this edition

Conversations

Netizen says wife planned to register child’s household registration in rural Hebei without discussion, sparking family-boundary dispute

Edition 2026-11-04 · 08:00 Beijing time

A V2EX user who says he is from the Hexi Corridor in Gansu and has lived in Beijing for many years posted that his wife, without consulting him in advance, asked her younger brother to arrange for their daughter’s hukou to be registered in rural Hebei. The wife said, “Hebei is better; it’s better for her to follow me.” The poster’s main grievance is that a major matter was not discussed, and he raised questions about independent judgment in marriage and boundaries with the family of origin.

The poster said he is from the Hexi Corridor in Gansu and has been in Beijing for many years. He married at 30, while his wife is from rural Hebei. The two met in Beijing and had a daughter when they were approaching 40. He had originally thought marriage meant building a life together, but they developed a strong disagreement over their child’s household registration.

According to the poster, his wife did not discuss or inform him in advance before preparing to register the child’s hukou in rural Hebei and having her younger brother begin the paperwork. When the poster asked why, his wife said, “Gansu is backward and poor; a child born there would be inferior to others. Hebei is better; it’s better for her to follow me.” The poster acknowledged that Gansu’s economic development is relatively behind, but he does not accept that birthplace determines a person’s worth, and he is unhappy that he was merely notified.

The poster also wrote that in his wife’s family of origin, his mother-in-law has strong decision-making power while his father-in-law is silent most of the time, leading him to wonder whether his wife is still influenced by her original family’s way of making decisions. He said he is not opposed to the child being registered in Hebei; the key is that policies, educational resources, and future prospects could be compared, but the child belongs to both of them and major decisions should be discussed first.

At the end, the poster framed the issue in terms of values in choosing a partner, independent thinking, distinguishing right from wrong, and establishing boundaries from one’s family of origin, and asked how he should handle the marriage now that his daughter has been born.

Original sources

V2EX ↗
Back to this editionOpen interactive reader