知Yizhi Daily
← Back to this edition

Conversations

Smart-home practitioner argues core functions should still work without internet

Edition 2026-11-11 · 08:00 Beijing time

A Hacker News user shared the local-first smart-home principles they have maintained for about a decade: core devices do not rely on vendor servers and continue working after an internet outage. Their setup uses ESP hardware, Tasmota, MQTT, and Node-RED, while retaining traditional controls such as wall switches.

The author said their top rule is “no internet is fine.” Reasons for designing it this way include Google changes that caused Nest integrations to stop working, a TLS certificate error appearing on a Samsung refrigerator screen, and a barbecue controller that had to connect to Wi-Fi just to display the temperature. They want important functions to run on hardware they own rather than being held hostage by changes in cloud services.

Their core setup includes ESP boards flashed with Tasmota, an MQTT message broker, and Node-RED running on a Raspberry Pi. The author also uses Alexa and some AWS cloud services, but Alexa is treated only as one entry point for switches; even if the cloud is unavailable, wall switches and wall-mounted control panels remain operable.

The rules they summarized also include: adding smart controls must not eliminate the original method of operation; automation should be easy to adjust as room uses and occupants change; review automations periodically to prevent multiple scheduled tasks from triggering the same device simultaneously; and exceptions must have a rationale that still seems valid six months later.

As the number of household members grew, the author also required cloud devices to provide an API with logs, otherwise they would not be installed; configuration should be centrally managed rather than scattered across multiple vendor apps; there should be more than one entry point, with operation possible through an app, Alexa, QR codes, or NFC tags; and devices publish and subscribe to messages through MQTT, while battery-powered devices should require battery replacement no more than once a year.

Original sources

Hacker News ↗
Back to this editionOpen interactive reader