知Yizhi Daily
← Back to this edition

Conversations

Study says diagnosing obesity by BMI alone causes substantial misclassification

Edition 2026-11-12 · 08:00 Beijing time

A study based on more than 800000 health records from the United Kingdom, the United States, China, and Spain concludes that using BMI alone to diagnose obesity misses obesity in 5% to 9% of adults while incorrectly labeling up to 3% as obese. A new approach combining waist circumference, waist-to-height ratio, and organ-function tests can better distinguish healthy people, preclinical obesity, and clinical obesity.

The material explains that the medical community has long considered body mass index, or BMI, a relatively crude tool for defining obesity. It may miss people with excessive body fat and may also misdiagnose some healthy people as obese. Francisco Rubino, professor of metabolic and bariatric surgery at King's College London, said that on a global scale this misclassification could involve tens of millions of people.

The new approach follows the diagnostic framework proposed last year by a Lancet commission report, combining BMI, other anthropometric indicators, and organ-function tests. The research team analyzed health records of more than 800000 people in the United Kingdom, the United States, China, and Spain and followed them for up to 15 years.

Under the new definition, people with a BMI over 40 are considered obese; those with a lower BMI must be checked for excess fat through indicators such as waist circumference. A BMI of 30 or above with an elevated waist circumference or waist-to-height ratio also counts as obesity; people with a BMI between 25 and 29.9 are classified as obese if both waist circumference and waist-to-height ratio are high. Reference thresholds in most countries are a waist circumference over 102 centimeters for men and over 88 centimeters for women, with a waist-to-height ratio of about 0.57.

The second diagnostic step distinguishes clinical obesity from preclinical obesity: the former is an active disease in which excess fat has already impaired organ function, while the latter means additional fat poses a health risk but has not yet caused problems. The study said that under the new definition, the overall obesity level rises only slightly, with one-quarter to one-third of obese people classified as clinically obese and having a significantly higher mortality risk.

The material also gives the example that three people with the same BMI of 32 may receive different diagnoses: one has no excess fat and is healthy, one has excess fat but no organ dysfunction, and another has both excess fat and organ dysfunction. The findings were published in Nature and show that 80% to 90% of people with preclinical obesity did not progress to clinical obesity over the following 10 years.

Original sources

Reddit Science ↗
Back to this editionOpen interactive reader