Conversations
Interviewer on autumn-recruiting graduates: impressive résumés, but weaknesses show under low-level follow-up questions
A user participating in autumn recruiting interviews posted that this year's fresh graduates overall have very strong résumés and communication skills. First authorship of CCF-A papers and two stints at major tech companies are not uncommon, and they can explain business and Agent practices clearly. However, when pressed on low-level principles such as LLM interfaces, prefill and decode, and KV cache, many cannot answer. He believes AI tools have intensified the “arms race” in job-search preparation.
Based on recent autumn recruiting interview experience, the poster said fresh graduates are at a very high overall level: many are first authors of CCF-A papers, two major-company internships have almost become standard, and their internship experiences often include concrete project details. When interviewees discuss business, domain knowledge, Agent construction, and evaluation methods, their answers are relatively comprehensive and reflect their own thinking; their résumés and communication skills are stronger than in the poster's own era.
But he observed that once questions extend slightly toward lower levels, shortcomings appear. For example, some cannot clearly explain how many categories tokens in an LLM interface are divided into or why billing differs, nor can they explain what prefill and decode each do. They have memorized standard QKV-related answers proficiently but cannot answer what KV cache stores or why long contexts become slower.
The poster compared this phenomenon to an “arms race” in school and job seeking: teachers use GPT to set questions, students use GPT to answer them, and teachers then use GPT to grade. AI can also assist with choosing paper topics, writing code, running experiments, and polishing writing, and traces of AI-organized interview boilerplate and mock interviews can likewise be seen in interview preparation.
He believes the result is that many students are in a state of “half-understanding”: they know concepts, terminology, and formulas, but they are exposed under deeper follow-up questions. Students themselves may also realize their foundations are weak, but because everyone around them is rushing forward, they do not have time to strengthen the basics. The poster stressed that these are his personal feelings as an interviewer and remarked that this year's competitive environment leaves him with complicated feelings.