Business & markets
European Court Adviser Recommends Retrial in Google AdSense Fine Annulment Case
An advocate general of the European Court of Justice issued an opinion questioning the EU General Court’s ruling annulling Google’s €1490000000 AdSense antitrust fine and recommending that the case be sent back for retrial. The opinion is not legally binding but typically receives close attention.
The European Court of Justice on the 12th published an opinion by Advocate General Juliane Kokott objecting to the EU General Court’s 2024 ruling annulling the fine in the Google advertising services case and recommending that the case be sent back for retrial.
The case involves Google’s AdSense advertising service, launched in 2003. In 2019, the European Commission found that Google had restricted or prohibited AdSense users from displaying competitors’ ads through exclusivity clauses between 2006 and 2016, and fined it €1490000000. After Google appealed, the EU General Court annulled the fine on grounds including that the EU had not adequately assessed the clauses’ impact, and the EU then appealed to the European Court of Justice.
The opinion argues that the EU did not need to assess the impact of exclusivity clauses on a case-by-case basis and could in principle conduct an overall assessment, and that the General Court set the bar too high and erred in its ruling. The opinion also notes that Google abolished or amended the relevant clauses in September 2016, and that the General Court should consider Google’s objections to the fine and reduce the penalty when retrying the case.