Conversations
Survey says nearly one-third of Amazon Black Friday–Cyber Monday “deals” did not save money
Groundwork Collaborative analyzed more than 350 products on Amazon’s own promotional pages for Black Friday and Cyber Monday in 2024 and 2025 and found that nearly one-third of “deals” were priced the same as or higher than in the month before the promotion, and nearly one-tenth were actually more expensive. The report is titled “Deal or Decoy?”
Report authors Breyon Williams, Elizabeth Pancotti, and Lindsay Owens examined products Amazon presented as the year’s “best” discounts. They concluded that nearly one-third of products were priced the same as or even higher during the promotional period than in the preceding month; nearly one-tenth of products cost more during Black Friday and Cyber Monday than customers could have bought them for in the previous month.
As an example, the report says that during Black Friday 2025, a pair of women’s Hunter short rain boots was listed at $126.99, while nine days before the promotion began the price was $79.97; based on those two prices, customers who waited for the promotion could have paid 59% more. The materials provided do not fully list all samples or the price-statistics methodology.
Lindsay Owens, chair and chief executive officer of Groundwork Collaborative and a co-author of the report, said many U.S. consumers wait all year for Black Friday and Cyber Monday to buy gifts and household essentials because they trust Amazon’s advertised discounts; she believes the survey shows these promotions may put consumers through “rip-off roulette,” and if Amazon cannot guarantee genuine deals, lawmakers should hold it accountable.
This survey examined prices on Amazon promotional pages and does not mean that every Black Friday–Cyber Monday product lacked a discount; the materials also do not provide Amazon’s response to the survey’s methodology or conclusions.